You take legal advice, gather the records and decide to defend a claim. Employment tribunal cover can pay eligible defence costs and compensation, but employment tribunal costs aren’t automatically recovered from the losing party.
That distinction matters when you’re setting a budget. Your defence bill, an employee’s compensation and an order to pay their costs are separate liabilities, with different rules behind them. Start by separating what your cover pays from what the tribunal can order.
Key takeaways
- Winning doesn’t automatically mean you recover what you paid your solicitor, and losing doesn’t automatically make you liable for the other side’s.
- Insurance can cover eligible defence costs and compensation, subject to its terms.
- Unreasonable conduct can create an additional costs risk, even where the underlying dispute started with a genuine disagreement.
What employment tribunal cover pays for
A tribunal claim creates several bills. Legal representation is one. Compensation, if the claim succeeds, is another. Management time spent finding emails and preparing witnesses adds a cost that won’t necessarily appear on either invoice.
Legal fees and representation
Defending a claim can involve reviewing documents, preparing the response, drafting witness statements and arranging representation at hearings. Expert evidence, such as a medical report, can add another expense.
Insurance-backed protection can meet eligible defence costs. The policy’s conditions, exclusions and limits still determine what is paid. Having cover doesn’t guarantee that every expense connected with a dispute is insured.
Compensation and financial awards
Compensation pays for the successful claim, rather than the work involved in defending it. Unfair dismissal compensation and discrimination compensation follow different rules. For discrimination claims, compensation has no statutory upper limit.
Our Employment Risk Cover provides insurance-backed protection of up to £250,000 for eligible defence costs and compensation, subject to policy terms and following our advice. That financial protection sits alongside the work needed to prevent and manage a claim.
Employment tribunal costs: who normally pays?
Employers and employees normally meet their own legal costs. Winning doesn’t automatically mean you recover your solicitor’s bill. Losing doesn’t automatically mean you pay the claimant’s.
Lawyers describe this as costs not “following the event”. You need a separate basis for a costs order.
Your defence budget remains your responsibility
A successful defence can still leave your business with legal fees, witness preparation and time away from normal work. Budget for those costs without assuming the claimant will reimburse them.
And don’t confuse a costs warning with a guaranteed recovery. A tribunal decides whether the legal threshold has been crossed.
There are no claim or hearing fees
There’s no fee to bring an employment tribunal claim in England, Wales or Scotland. Following the Supreme Court’s July 2017 ruling, tribunal fees stopped on 27 July 2017.
Northern Ireland has separate legislation and tribunal procedures. The costs rules discussed here concern Great Britain.
When can a tribunal order someone to pay costs?
Costs orders are discretionary. The Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2024 (the applicable employment tribunal rules), SI 2024/1155, govern the process for making a costs award.
The same conduct rules matter to employers and claimants. A weak response or unreasonable defence can expose your business to an order too.
Claims without reasonable prospects and unreasonable conduct
A tribunal can consider costs where a claim or response had no reasonable prospect of success. Vexatious, abusive, disruptive or otherwise unreasonable conduct can also trigger an application.
Practical safeguards include the following:
- Disclose relevant documents, including evidence that weakens your position.
- Give truthful evidence and correct mistakes promptly.
- Follow tribunal directions and meet deadlines.
- Attend hearings, or explain promptly why attendance isn’t possible.
An unsuccessful argument doesn’t automatically become unreasonable conduct. The tribunal looks at what the party did and whether that crossed the relevant threshold.
Settlement offers and late withdrawal
Rejecting a sensible settlement offer can become relevant to costs, particularly where continuing the case was unreasonable. Rejection alone doesn’t automatically justify an order.
A late decision to withdraw claim proceedings can leave the other side with avoidable preparation costs. Give notice as early as possible when your position changes.
A costs warning should identify the conduct complained about and the financial consequences. It shouldn’t treat losing as proof of unreasonable behaviour.
Costs orders and preparation time orders explained
These orders deal with different forms of expenditure. Neither is an automatic payment to the winner.
What a costs order can include
A costs order can cover legal fees for preparing the case, representation at the hearing and relevant expenses, including expert witness fees.
The tribunal decides what should be recovered. A bill isn’t recoverable simply because someone paid it. If applicable rules justify it, the tribunal must direct assessment on the indemnity basis, but that doesn’t make every item recoverable.
A wasted costs order is different again. It concerns costs caused by a representative’s improper, unreasonable or negligent conduct, rather than an ordinary disagreement about the merits of a claim.
How preparation time is calculated
A preparation time order concerns qualifying work done while a party wasn’t legally represented. For litigants in person, only qualifying preparation time may be recoverable. Time spent by an unpaid adviser isn’t automatically a recoverable fee. The tribunal assesses reasonable and proportionate preparation hours. Time at the final hearing isn’t included.
For work done between 6 April 2026 and 5 April 2027, the rate is £46 an hour. Ten qualifying hours therefore produces a calculation of 10 × £46 = £460.
Keep a record of the task, date and time spent. A claimant can’t recover legal costs and preparation time twice for the same work.
Applying for or responding to a costs order
A costs application needs evidence of the conduct complained about and the amount sought. A broad accusation that the other side wasted your time isn’t enough.
The application deadline
An application can be made during proceedings or no later than 28 days after the final judgment is sent to the parties. That’s different from counting 28 days from the hearing.
Build the application around three things:
- Identify the conduct or lack of reasonable prospects relied on.
- Explain the costs that resulted and provide a clear schedule.
- Give the other party a proper opportunity to respond.
If your business receives an application, address both the alleged conduct and the amount claimed. They are separate questions.
Whether someone can afford to pay
The tribunal may consider the paying party’s ability to pay, but it doesn’t have to. Limited resources don’t automatically prevent an award.
Citizens Advice recommends that a claimant facing an employer’s costs application prepares a statement of income, outgoings and savings.
Financial evidence must be accurate. Misleading the tribunal about available money can create further problems, rather than reduce the amount payable.
What Cairns shows about costs risk
In Cairns v The Wellness Zone, Case No. 2414495/2021, the tribunal ordered the claimant to pay £20,000 in costs.
The findings included unreasonable conduct and untruthful or misleading evidence on central matters. The tribunal also considered means under Rule 84 of the rules applicable to that case.
The award reached the maximum available through the specific-amount route. Under the 2024 rules, that route appears in Rule 76. It isn’t an overall ceiling on all costs liability.
The practical point is straightforward. Tribunals can make substantial orders when conduct warrants them. But this decision doesn’t mean a claimant who loses should expect a £20,000 bill. The conduct findings mattered.
Keep your advice, actions and evidence together
A policy can explain what managers should do. Your records show what they actually did.
For disciplinary decisions, retain the allegations, investigation material, meeting notes, advice and reasons for the outcome. Our disciplinary process and evidence tools help keep that material together.
Training records matter too. A written equality policy alone doesn’t establish that your business took all reasonable steps to prevent discrimination. Relevant, effective training can support that defence, alongside the actions managers took.
And remember that employment tribunal judgments and full written reasons are generally published, subject to exceptions. That can have consequences for business reputation and an individual’s future employment.
Good records support your defence. They also help you make a realistic settlement decision before further costs build up.
Frequently asked questions
How much does it cost to defend an employment tribunal?
There’s no single defence price. The bill depends on the claims, document volume, witnesses, preliminary hearings and hearing length.
Ask for a staged budget covering the response, disclosure, witness statements and hearing. Keep management time separate so finance can see the full commitment.
Where insurance applies, the policy determines which costs are met. A successful defence doesn’t itself make those costs recoverable from the claimant.
Can an employee get legal aid?
In England and Wales, legal aid may be available for employment discrimination advice, subject to eligibility. It isn’t general funding for every employment dispute or ordinary unfair dismissal representation. Scotland has separate arrangements.
The availability of funding doesn’t decide whether a claim has merit. Employers should assess the evidence and legal issues, rather than assume an unrepresented claimant has a weak case.
Put financial protection behind your process
Employment tribunal costs need a budget even when you expect to win. Keep the defence bill, possible compensation and any separate costs application distinct.
Our employment protection solution, created by award-winning lawyers, combines human resources consultancy, software, learning and legal advice at one predictable price per employee, with insurance-backed protection. The aim is documented decisions, supported before a claim arrives.
Book an intro call to discuss bringing your HR support, records and tribunal protection together.